SIBO is real. The testing is the problem.
Few topics in gut health divide opinion like SIBO. On one side are people who spent years feeling bloated, finally got a positive breath test and found a treatment that worked; on the other are gastroenterologists who think it's being diagnosed far too often. As it happens, both sides have a point.
What SIBO is
Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth means there are too many bacteria in the small intestine, which normally holds far fewer than the large bowel. Those bacteria ferment food earlier than they should and produce gas, so bloating is the most common symptom, often alongside wind, pain, diarrhoea or nausea.
Some things make it more likely, including long-term use of acid-suppressing drugs such as omeprazole, opioid painkillers, previous bowel surgery and conditions that slow the gut down.
Mainstream medicine does recognise it
You'll read online that doctors don't believe in SIBO, but that isn't right. The American College of Gastroenterology published a full clinical guideline on it in 2020, covering both diagnosis and treatment, and the main treatment it recommends is an antibiotic called rifaximin, which mostly stays inside the gut.
The real argument isn't about whether SIBO exists; it's about how you tell who has it.
The testing problem
The most accurate test involves taking a sample of fluid from the small intestine during an endoscopy and growing the bacteria in a lab, which is invasive and rarely done. Most people get a breath test instead, where you drink a sugar solution and then breathe into tubes every 15 to 20 minutes. If bacteria in your small intestine ferment the sugar, the levels of hydrogen or methane in your breath go up.
The trouble lies in the detail. Different labs use different cut-offs: the 2017 North American consensus treats a hydrogen rise of 20 parts per million within 90 minutes as positive, while some UK labs and devices use a smaller rise over a shorter window. The choice of sugar matters too. Lactulose isn't absorbed, so in someone whose gut moves quickly it can reach the large bowel within 90 minutes and produce a false positive, whereas glucose is absorbed early on and can miss overgrowth further down.
Methane is a separate story, because it's made by archaea rather than bacteria. The ACG now calls high methane "intestinal methanogen overgrowth" (IMO for short) and links it with constipation.
The upshot is that the same person can test positive at one lab and negative at another. Even the ACG guideline's own authors rate almost all of their recommendations as resting on very low-quality evidence, which is honest of them and well worth knowing before you spend any money.
What to do with this
If you have persistent bloating, start with your GP so they can rule out the basics, such as coeliac disease, inflammation and low iron. If SIBO still seems likely after that, especially if one of the risk factors above applies to you, a breath test is a reasonable next step. Ask which sugar and which cut-off the lab uses, make sure it measures methane as well as hydrogen, and treat a positive result as one piece of evidence rather than a final verdict.
It's also worth being wary of anyone who diagnoses SIBO without a test, or who goes straight to long and expensive herbal protocols; the ACG advises against treating without testing first.
Where Muna fits
Muna can go through a breath test report with you, explain what the numbers mean against the main cut-offs and show you the research behind it. What she can't do is tell you for certain whether you have SIBO, but then nobody can from a breath test alone.
Sources: Pimentel M et al. ACG Clinical Guideline: Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth. Am J Gastroenterol 2020; Rezaie A et al. Hydrogen and methane-based breath testing in gastrointestinal disorders: the North American Consensus. Am J Gastroenterol 2017; AGIP best practice statement for hydrogen/methane breath testing, hosted by BSG.